Martin’s Villa or Fairmount, Chatham, N.J.

Version 7.1 of the list (pdf) has only a few new buildings, by far the most interesting of which is one that Hugh Lamb advertised on the back of the 1877 Newark city directory:

Martin's Villa, Chatham, N.J. by Hugh Lamb
Martin’s Villa (Fairmount?), Chatham, N.J.

This might be the grand mansion built on Long Hill (Fairmount Avenue) by William A. Martin of New York, a wholesale liquor dealer (or tea importer?). It does not look like Fairview House, the long-time hotel apparently established by a William Martin.

Incidentally, Lamb first appears — as an architect — in Newark in a directory published in 1868. He seems to have been a draftsman, but the directories do not indicate which firm he was with. He would have been only 19 or 20.

Posted in Building information, General, Requests for information, Research, Site updates | Comments closed

The Woman’s Apartment House Association

Version 7.0 of the list (pdf) has been posted. Along with a minor reorganization and the dropping of Rich’s Charlottesville house as far too late to include, these are some of the changes:

  • An interesting unbuilt Woman’s Apartment House Association design is noted. This was an answer to the popular bachelor apartment of the 1890s — for “girl bachelors,” women who were frustrated at being turned away from restaurants after 9 pm when not accompanied by a man.
  • The New Rochelle apartment building has finally been given a tentative identification.
  • “Pine Tree Point” of J.B. Taylor in the Thousand Islands has been conclusively identified.
  • The firm designed a competition entry for the St. Joseph County Courthouse in South Bend, Ind.
Posted in Building information, General, Site updates | Comments closed

Pratt Manor, of course

Version 6.5 of the list (pdf) was posted a while back. Recent additions include:

  • Pratt Manor or “the Manor House,” at Glen Cove, Charles Pratt’s ca. 1890 alteration of an existing house. The house was moved and replaced by Pratt’s son John Teele Pratt around 1912. The son’s replacement, called “the Manor,” was designed by Charles Platt, which accounts for the present confusion.
  • Unbuilt design for Alpha Delta Phi house at Amherst College.
  • The big attribution: Anderson Hall at the Oneida Baptist Institute in Kentucky (University of Louisville photo), almost certainly the “Mrs. Anderson Kentucky school” designed by Charles A. Rich.
  • An 1892 addition to a Tinpan Alley building commissioned by Charles Baron von Woodcock Savage, a “favorite” of the King of Württemberg and the subject of a fascinating article by Ned Katz.
  • A tentative attribution for the W.H.H. James house at around 80 Munn Avenue in East Orange.
Posted in Building information, General, Site updates | Comments closed

Short Hills Congregational Church, unbuilt

Version 6.4 of the list (pdf) is up.

New are the references to Wheeler’s two tenements for John F. Gleason (a consolidation of references to Gleason and “Mr. Mason”; not sure whether Gleason is the famous billiards man of that name); the sports pavilion at the Berkeley Oval (not the same as the Berkeley Oval Cottage, apparently); and a flamboyant unbuilt design for Short Hills Congregational Church.

The strange disjunction between the number of houses apparently built in Henderson Place, thirty-two, and the repeated reference to the Lamb & Rich project as containing forty houses might be closer to a solution. It turns out that a year or so before work began, Lamb & Wheeler filed plans for a dozen houses on a plot adjoining the site to the west, on East 86th Street. A hospital has occupied that site since the early 1900s, and it is difficult to tell whether this original dozen was built. It seems doubtful.

Posted in Building information, General, Requests for information | Comments closed

Butler Manor demolished

The Preservation League of Staten Island writes that the Rich-designed Butler Manor has been demolished.

Secret Staten Island has photos.

[Update 10.24.2010: Preservation magazine has an online story.]

Posted in Building information, General, Threatened buildings | Comments closed

Colonial Revival mania in Sharon, Connecticut

Sharon has a number of genuinely Colonial buildings, but it has more buildings erected in the Colonial style at the turn of the Twentieth Century.

While Lamb & Rich are known for the Romanesque monument on the Green in Sharon, the Wheeler Memorial Clock Tower, their other projects in town have not been identified.

The firm designed two houses and an addition to a Colonial house for Emily O. Wheeler, an addition for her sister Emily and her husband, Charles Comfort Tiffany, and projects for McClurg, Schuyler, and Van Renssalaer that might be located in Sharon.

Posted in Building information, General, Requests for information | Comments closed

Lawrence Hall, precursor of Lawrence Woodmere Academy

The Lawrence element of Lawrence Woodmere Academy traces its history back to a private school established by the Lawrence Association in Lawrence, Long Island in 1891. Information on the Association’s original building, apparently a combination schoolroom and meeting hall called Lawrence Hall, is difficult to find.

The building was definitely built, however, and was supported by Association members Frederick B. Lord and George C. Rand. Lamb & Rich completed a school for Rand in 1891 that might be Lawrence Hall.

Posted in Building information, General, Requests for information, Research | Comments closed

More pseudonyms in Short Hills

William I. Russell’s 1913 autobiography The Romance and Tragedy of a Widely Known Business Man of New York uses pseudonyms almost exclusively. Some people’s identities may be figured out based on the proximity of their houses in Short Hills, New Jersey. Others depend on characterization:

[Manufacturing jeweler "Ned Banford"] said his own capital was very small and a wealthy friend, a Mr. Viedler, was backing him, and at that time had ten thousand dollars in his business. He enlarged on the liberality of this friend, saying, amongst other things, that when he went to him for money he never asked anything further than, “How much do you want, Ned”? and then writing a cheque would hand it to him.

He also told me that his business was very profitable and the only disadvantage he labored under was Mr. Viedler’s frequent absence. . . .

It was with our New York friends that most of our social life was passed. The circle there had been enlarged by the addition of many pleasant people, although the close intimacy still rested where it had started, with, however, the addition of Mr. and Mrs. William Viedler.

Mr. Viedler, a multi-millionaire at that time, has since largely increased his fortune and is now the controlling interest in a prominent trust of comparatively recent formation. They had been Brooklynites but bought a fine house on Fifth Avenue. We first met them on the occasion of a dinner given in their honor by Mr. and Mrs. Curtice, to welcome them to New York. Mr. Curtice is a nephew of Mrs. Viedler. . . . [The inner circle] comprised Mr. and Mrs. Curtice, Mr. and Mrs. Todd, Mr. and Mrs. Banford, Mr. and Mrs Viedler, and ourselves Curtice was our poet laureate[.]

Russell, 157-161.

It seems likely that:

  • “Viedler” is George Frederick Vietor (1839-1910);
  • his wife, the former Miss “Curtice,” is Anna Margaretha (Achelis) Veitor (1847-1927); and
  • her “nephew” “Will Curtice” is actually her brother Fritz Achelis, with his wife Bertha.
    • Anna Vietor’s real nephew was Frederic George Achelis, who married Helen Bruff Achelis, but he was a child in the early 1890s when the book’s events are taking place.

It is not clear who “Ned Banford” was.

[Update 09.18.2011: Thanks to a generous reader, "Ned Banford" has been identified as Edward F. Sanford of E.F. Sanford & Co., jewelers or diamond dealers. His wife Anna M. Sanford was a prominent golfer during the early 1900s.]

Posted in General, Requests for information, Research | Comments closed

Who designed Pine Tree Point?

Who designed the original “Pine Tree Point” house on Point Marguerite/Point Anthony at Alexandria Bay in the Thousand Islands, New York? John B. Taylor commissioned the imposing stone summer cottage in the early 1920s. It might have been Rich & Mathesius, since the firm referred to Taylor projects in 1920 and 1921.

The building seems to have burned several years after Taylor sold it. The current Pine Tree Point is a relatively recent replacement.

Version 6.3 of the list (pdf) has been posted. It contains a few changes and corrections.

[Update 01.09.2011: Charles A. Rich definitely designed Pine Tree Point.]

Posted in Building information, General, Requests for information, Research, Site updates | Comments closed

New version of catalog — Thomas House in Saratoga Springs

Version 6.2 of the list (pdf) includes several new attributions, including a tentative identification of the Thomas House at 72 Union Avenue in Saratoga Springs. It appears to have been built for George West, Jr. in 1903 and was used for a number of years as the Skidmore College administration building:


72 Union Avenue

The house was put up for sale in 2009, and there is a video showing a few interiors:


72 Union Avenue

The house was apparently owned for some time by Mary Harrison McKee, daughter of former president Benjamin Harrison.

Other new identifications will be posted this week. Updates on the Butler Manor situation will be posted as information comes in.

Posted in Building information, General, Research, Site updates | Comments closed